Captain Nuhu Musa is the director general of the Nigeria Civil Aviation Authority (NCAA), in this interview with aviation journalists he reacted to the foreign airlines trapped funds, saying that airlines are in business to make money and that the Bilateral Air Service Agreement (BASA) arrangements state that they should be allowed to repatriate their funds without hindrance. Hence, the NCAA cannot force any of them to remain in Nigeria. Among other issues, he talked about the airlines’ indebtedness to the agency, stating that the NCAA has put a measure in place to prevent the debts from growing.
Excerpts
Assent to Civil Aviation Act 2022 and effect for aviation
Since the Civil Aviation act 2006, there has been significant changes in the industry; we have had new annexes in the International Civil Aviation Organisation (ICAO), new developments in terms of ICT, and environments in the industry generally.
In addition to that the service providers namely; the Nigeria Airspace Management Agency (NAMA) and Federal Airports Authority of Nigeria (FAAN) have some residual regulatory functions in them and those regulatory functions have been removed and moved to NCAA as the regulator of the industry to avoid conflict of interest.
“You cannot provide service and also regulate some of the services you provide. Those are the main things that we have in the new Civil Aviation Act 2022. Of course, there are other changes that are with the view to have a much more efficient, effective air transportation industry and to make sure Nigeria complies with the new ICAO standards, new annexes and international best practices.”
CBN release of trapped funds and efforts of NCAA to prevent some airlines from leaving Nigeria as planned
Airlines are businesses like any other business that investors make money and the Bilateral Air Service Agreement (BASA) arrangements state that they should be allowed to repatriate their funds without hindrance.
Unfortunately because of the challenges this country is facing, the funds accumulated and became very high. It is a welcome development that CBN had released a significant amount of these funds and going forward, I know the Minister of Aviation, Senator Hadi Sirika, the Minister of Finance and the CBN governor are still working to ensure the balance of the funds are released to the airlines and a mechanism is developed to avoid the repeat of this.
“If you remember when this government first came into power; 2015 and early 2016, there was the same case of about $600 million, which through the efforts of the minister ensured the funds were released to the airlines, but unfortunately, six, seven years later, we found ourselves in the same conundrum, but I know all efforts are being made at the high level to settle this.”
“But, we cannot force any airline to operate in Nigeria; we can encourage them, we can talk to them, but it is a commercial decision for an airline to decide a number of frequencies and where they operate to. If the passenger load is not there, you cannot force them to operate. If they believe they have other difficulties and challenges that affect their operations into certain airports, it is their decision. I cannot force or manipulate any airline to operate in Nigeria. We can only encourage them.”
When do you think the remaining trapped funds would be released?
I don’t have the slightest idea. My prayer is that it should be released like yesterday. “Nigeria currently has some challenges with the issue of foreign exchange, but we hope it is released as soon as possible so that normal services can resume and not be interrupted. Nigerians travel a lot and air transport is critical for the economy of our country. So, we hope these funds are paid as soon as possible.”
Summary of the closed door meeting with airlines and ground handling companies
We have discussed and that was why we had a closed door meeting and it was a much calmer meeting. We all agreed; everybody is having challenges, difficulties and this is not restricted to the industry stakeholders alone, the airlines, ground handlers and other service providers.
Even the agencies, we have the same problem in the issues of funds. At a point in time during the COVID-19 pandemic when the airlines ran into troubles, a lot of the agencies too had the same challenges of paying the salaries of their workers. So we are all in the same boat. You can imagine FAAN running about 27 airports and the funds are not there, NAMA has facilities all over the country that they must maintain, equipment are imported and they must be maintained. I had to train my inspectors overseas.
We are all in the same boat and we all need to work together, collaborate and get out of the problem. We need to stabilise the system and ensure there is improvement.
Also, there are issues of the outstanding debts that need to be paid. So, we are working on the airlines, we know that if we tell them to give us all these monies at the same time, it is very difficult and not possible, so, what we have put in place in NCAA and to prevent the debts from growing is a tripartite agreement; the NCAA, airlines and the airlines’ banks.
So, once those funds go to the bank, the five per cent TSA/CSC automatically deducts and goes into the NCAA bank and NCAA will share it with the other sister agencies on a pre-determined ratio as entrenched in the 2006 Civil Aviation Act.
For the legacy debts, what we have done is to enter a MoU with all the operators; we know they can’t pay all at a time, but they have to pay us a reasonable amount of money on a monthly basis at least. I think almost all the airlines are complying with this, except a few that we are working on.
What we have said is that if they don’t pay this legacy debt, we are not going to renew their licenses; Air Operators Certificate (AOC) and ATL.
That is one of the conditions and most of them have entered into the agreement. My account people are sitting with them so that they can make an arrangement on payment of a reasonable amount so that the debts can be cleared off over a short or middle time period.
Audit of five domestic airlines and the outcome
Yes, the airlines have challenges; we have sat down with some of them, discussed with them and some of them need some injections of funds. Like Aero decided to shut down on its own volition and they are reorganising, getting more aircraft, expecting some injection of funds so that their financial status can grow. So, we are in discussions with them on this matter.
Financial distress in aviation if not managed properly could turn out to be a safety issue because we don’t want airlines to start to cut corners.
Those with financial difficulties if you notice, they are delaying flights, cancelling flights, but we need to work with them. We are all in this together, except where we have serious concerns in the continued existence of the airlines or serious violation, we will work with them hand on hand so that they can be able to get out of these financial challenges they found themselves in.
Update on Dana Air
Dana was not only on the financial issue, there were other violations in conjunction with the weak financial position. We are working with Dana assiduously to see how the issue can be resolved. Even yesterday (Monday), we had an internal zoom meeting with the airline and a couple of things need to be completed and we will call our management.
Dana will sit down with them, they will tell us what they have done and what they have put in place. If we are happy, we release them, but if not, we will tell them what they must do before they are released for safe operations.
“Safety of the industry is paramount and it will never be compromised.”